You are here: Home ‣ Dive Into HTML5 ‣
HOW DID WE GET HERE?
Show table of contents
Ecently, I stumbled across a quote from a Mozilla developer about the tension inherent in creating standards:
Implementations and specifications have to do a delicate dance together. You don’t want implementations to happen before the specification is finished, because people start depending on the details of implementations and that constrains the specification. However, you also don’t want the specification to be finished before there are implementations and author experience with those implementations, because you need the feedback. There is unavoidable tension here, but we just have to muddle on through.
Keep this quote in the back of your mind, and let me explain how HTML5 came to be.
This book is about HTML5, not previous versions of HTML, and not any version of XHTML. But to understand the history of HTML5
and the motivations behind it, you need to understand a few technical details first. Specifically, MIME types.
Every time your web browser requests a page, the web server sends “headers” before it sends the actual page markup. These headers are normally invisible, although there are web development tools that will make them visible if you’re interested. But the headers are important, because they tell your browser how to interpret the page markup that follows. The most important header is called Content-Type, and it looks like this:
Of course, reality is more complicated than that. The first generation of web servers (and I’m talking web servers from 1993) didn’t send the Content-Type header because it didn’t exist yet. (It wasn’t invented until 1994.) For compatibility reasons that date all the way back to 1993, some popular web browsers will ignore the Content-Type header under certain circumstances. (This is called “content sniffing.”) But as a general rule of thumb, everything you’ve ever looked at on the web – HTML pages, images, scripts, videos, PDFs, anything with a URL – has been served to you with a specific MIME type in the Content-Type header.
Tuck that under your hat. We’ll come back to it.
A LONG DIGRESSION INTO HOW STANDARDS ARE MADE
Why do we have an element? That’s not a question you hear every day. Obviously someone must have created it. These things don’t just appear out of nowhere. Every element, every attribute, every feature of HTML that you’ve ever used – someone created them, decided how they should work, and wrote it all down. These people are not gods, nor are they flawless. They’re just people. Smart people, to be sure. But just people.
One of the great things about standards that are developed “out in the open” is that you can go back in time and answer these kinds of questions. Discussions occur on mailing lists, which are usually archived and publicly searchable. So I decided to do a bit of “email archaeology” to try to answer the question, “Why do we have an element?